The Main Street America Group

Main Street America

A Long History of Service

The Main Street America Group was founded in 1923 in Keene, N.H. when the Grange Fraternity created an entity to provide affordable insurance to its members. Today, Main Street America, a super-regional property and casualty company, provides personal lines, commercial lines, and fidelity and surety bond products to individuals, families, and small businesses in 22 States through five carriers: NGM Insurance Company, Old Dominion Insurance Company, Main Street America Assurance Company, MSA Insurance Company, and Great Lakes Casualty Insurance Company. They are headquartered in Jacksonville F.L. with field offices throughout the United States.

Backed by Financial Strength

Main Street America's products and services are backed by financial strength. They are rated "A" (Excellent) by A.M. Best, the insurance industry's premier rating organization.

A Full Product Line

For consumers, they offer competitively priced homeowners, auto, and umbrella products. Their commercial product line includes businessowners policy, commercial auto, workers' compensation, and umbrella. They also provide contract/construction, fidelity, and commercial surety bond products for a wide range of businesses and individuals.

Delivering Exceptional Customer Service

The Main Street America Group was recently ranked #3 for automobile claims satisfaction by the NY State Insurance department. This is a ranking they are very proud of.

Contact Information

Website: (opens in a new tab)


(877) 425-2467

Make a Payment (opens in a new tab)

Billing Address:
55 West Street
Keene, NH 03431

Writing Companies

  • NGM Insurance Company
  • Old Dominion Insurance Company
  • Main Street America Assurance Company
  • MSA Insurance Company
  • Great Lakes Casualty Insurance Company
  • Main Street America Protection Insurance Company

Home Office Address

The Main Street America Group
4601 Touchton Road East, Suite 3400
Jacksonville, FL 32246

Stan Steele Insurance
Stan Steele Agency, Inc.
55 State Street
Bloomfield, NY 14469